Skip to content Skip to footer

Moving from the Outside, In: Socialists Legislating With the Grassroots

by
Article published:

Part two of Paul Pinsky’s lessons from serving as a socialist in the Maryland state legislature for over 30 years.

As an increasing number of democratic socialists and progressives run for and win state and local offices, they need a roadmap for how to strategize, organize and thrive once they get there. It’s easy to feel isolated and rudderless, particularly without leftwing colleagues to caucus with. I’m here to help.

I’ve been an activist all my life—an anti-war protester, a union organizer, a 36-year state legislator, and a top official in state government. I’ve stayed true to my progressive principles through the decades, and learned a lot about politics, about making your way in a hostile world—and most important, about making a difference.

In the first installment of this series, I talked about my background, my political moorings, and some of the challenges I encountered as I began to build my political career. While the political times and climate have changed, I think the lessons from my experience are still quite valuable. 

A caveat: None of these lessons will apply all of the time; circumstances can change over the course of a legislative debate, and you have to be prepared to be nimble. Sometimes you may need to encourage allies to take small wins. Other times you may see the possibility of building support for more substantial gains—even when advocates you work with want to take less and claim an immediate victory.

Slow media for fast times. Sign up for our newsletter.

I introduced an explicit piece of single-payer legislation and then met with groups of doctors, nurses, and single-payer advocates—along with some progressive labor unions—to plan a hearing on the bill and start building support.

Some of the most important lessons I learned pivoted around relationships with movement groups, with other legislators, and with my constituents. When I entered the legislature, left activists weren’t thinking deeply about the relationships between electoral work and other organizing, elected officials and movement groups, protest and advocacy and governing. I learned on the job, and activists today are looking at the web of relations much more closely, understanding electeds as part of an ecosystem.

#1) Work hard at building relationships with groups with real roots.

In any legislative fight, left lawmakers need the support of organizations that can deliver people and not just speeches and press releases. Lots of groups these days exist only on paper. At crunch time, they can only deliver at best a handful of people to any sort of campaign mobilization. 

I introduced an explicit piece of single-payer legislation and then met with groups of doctors, nurses, and single-payer advocates—along with some progressive labor unions—to plan a hearing on the bill and start building support.

These paper groups do have their roles, and left legislators do need to work with them. But the difference-makers in actual struggles will always be the groups that truly do have the capacity to organize and mobilize. 

Some years ago, the largest immigrant rights group in my state, CASA of Maryland, proposed a fundamental change in existing education law that would allow immigrants to receive in-state tuition rates at two- and four-year colleges if they attended high school in Maryland. CASA considered this legislation a top priority and mobilized heavily behind it. 

CASA’s leaders asked me to be their legislation’s point person on the Senate floor. They expected a rough time, with fierce attacks from Republicans and even some Democrats. 

As the floor leader, I would have responsibility for defending the bill and deciding whether to accept or oppose amendments that might come up. I had to be prepared for the nuances. I remember the Sunday before the floor debate in CASA’s office getting tutored by the group’s lawyers.

The next day, during the floor debate, nearly 35 amendments came before me. Most, predictably, sought to weaken the bill. Over the course of a day-long debate, we Senate supporters of the legislation successfully fended off the worst of the amendment moves. We owed that success to a true coupling of legislative know-how and grassroots energy and expertise. 

Without that cooperation, nothing at all ever changes.

Another similar coupling came a few years after I entered the Senate. The previous year, climate legislation that would have restricted emissions from coal-fired power plants—and required Maryland to start taxing emissions through a Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative—had died in the House.

Climate advocates decided to try again on the bill the next year, starting this time in the Senate. I became the bill’s lead sponsor. After strategizing with the environmental groups, we renamed the bill the “Healthy Air Act” and then reached out to the public health community, a step that hadn’t happened the year before. With nurses, doctors, and public health experts now in the coalition, we flooded the legislative halls of Annapolis, another step that hadn’t been taken the year before.

That mass mobilization made a difference. The corporate energy giants found themselves suddenly isolated. The bill passed.

More recently, Maryland education leaders wanted to revamp the state’s funding formulas for schools and investigate successful educational approaches from around the country and world. They backed legislation that, once enacted, created a two-year study commission to come up with a plan to move a new state education agenda. I served on that commission. Our panel heard, as expected, some riveting expert testimony. A bit less expected: The two-year-long process helped nurture an unofficial coalition between education unions, advocates for the poor, and state education and civic leaders.  

Not everyone would be on our fledgling coalition’s wavelength. Republicans opposed the price tag of the recommendations our commission produced. The state association of counties opposed the new cost “burdens” those recommendations placed at the county level. Some local school boards objected to the new instructional strategies our commission advanced. 

But our core group of advocates held together. Lawmakers adopted the commission’s cutting-edge recommendations, measures that ranged from a $60,000 annual starting salary for teachers to strict standards for school and state accountability.

On health care, progressive lawmakers and groups with real roots couldn’t quite capture the same magic. Maryland has long seemed a potential site for a real breakthrough on establishing a single-payer health care system.  Maryland already had a unique existing arrangement that essentially left the door open to an all-payer rate-setting system for hospital services.

To open that door wider, I introduced an explicit piece of single-payer legislation and then met with groups of doctors, nurses, and single-payer advocates—along with some progressive labor unions—to plan a hearing on the bill and start building support.

Single-payer hearings would become an annual event over the next few years. We would bring in health policy experts, union leaders, and grassroots advocates for each hearing. Members of the Senate panel with jurisdiction paid attention, but the press didn’t. We received little coverage. The Senate panel members soon stopped paying attention as well. Single-payer? Just Pinsky, their attitude became, “being Pinsky.”

What did our single-payer campaign end up achieving? We did gain a number of sponsors for the single-payer legislation. We forced other lawmakers to put up or shut up. But the reality remains that close cooperation between left lawmakers and advocacy groups can’t guarantee success. Sometimes that cooperation can’t even move the needle. 

The one certainty: Without that cooperation, nothing at all ever changes.

#2) Identify lawmaker allies you can trust through good times and bad.

How can you tell who in your legislative chamber could be more than a mere legislative “colleague”? Who could become a real ally, a partner in struggle. Who could help you push the legislative envelope.

As a left lawmaker, you’ll quickly see that your legislative colleagues come in quite an assortment of behavioral shapes and sizes. Some will be eager to stand up on contentious issues and take a strong, progressive position. Some will be equally as eager to co-sponsor your envelope-pushing legislative initiatives. Progressive advocacy groups will often direct you to their long-time supporters and vouch for their progressive bona fides.

…all the good allies and friends in high places won’t move your agenda particularly far unless you take pains to always be as nimble legislatively as possible, to be able to take advantage of unexpected situations.

You’ll soon also quickly see that other lawmakers rate as no more than political posers. They’ll stand up initially for good issues, but later prove to have no ideological grounding. Others who will define themselves as “good liberals” will avoid adding their name to any bill that challenges the corporate sector or dares to restrict how the state police operate.

As a state lawmaker, I early on found a few true progressive allies as well as principled traditional liberals I could join with on select issues. I also found some unlikely allies, through my previous work as an educator and my service on various legislative workgroups. That joint work helped me build the sort of trust that won me the support of an important committee chairman on our successful efforts to make community college tuition-free.

Besides finding the right people to work with, left lawmakers also need to identify the policies that will both have a shot at resonating with their colleagues and, at the same time, help push the political envelope.  

Where to start that process? Follow your core interests. Try to gain committee or subcommittee assignments related to your areas of expertise. Your legislative chamber’s presiding officer may even accommodate your preferences. Your long-range goal here? To become the go-to lawmaker on a particular issue or issues. That status can be invaluable, even if it won’t necessarily shield you from attacks.

But all the good allies and friends in high places won’t move your agenda particularly far unless you take pains to always be as nimble legislatively as possible, to be able to take advantage of unexpected situations.

One of those opportunities arose in the battle to pass an omnibus Climate Solutions Now Act. This massive bill included a section requiring the planting of five million trees in Maryland over a 10-year period, with at least 500,000 of these trees planted in underserved urban areas where the trees could absorb carbon dioxide and provide shade and other benefits.

With this omnibus bill floundering, a different bill the natural resources community simply had to have came before my committee. I amended the five-million tree provision from the floundering bill onto this other legislation and, for an exclamation point, renamed the bill the Tree Solutions Now Act. The bill passed and became law – a reminder that you have to keep your eyes open for unexpected opportunities and use every legislative tool available to achieve your goals.

#3) Invest your time in communicating to your community.

Serving as a lawmaker gives you a platform, not just a vote in a legislative chamber. As an “elected,” your voice can reach a much wider public than activists can normally reach. You get invites to speak before community and civic groups. Editors give your op-eds high-priority attention. You can hold news conferences that the media will actually cover. You can distribute newsletters, electronically and through the mail, to your constituents. 

Left lawmakers need to seize all these opportunities to reach the general public and expand that public’s horizons. Indeed, as a progressive thinker and activist, you need to see communicating as central to your mission, a core part of your job. As an elected leader, you might not be a Bernie or an AOC, but your outreach efforts, if conducted consistently, can offer a counter narrative to dominant corporate class messages.

Not using your status as a left lawmaker to educate, agitate, and organize would amount to a gross dereliction of your duties! 

“Going public” can serve other purposes as well. Your communications can show that you’re fighting the good fight on behalf of working families and build confidence in your leadership. Your outreach can also be the flame that helps isolated activists—and potential activists—become more involved in ongoing struggles. Tapping their energy and expertise can bolster your legislative and campaign efforts and, at the same time, help make their lives more fulfilling.

To be effective, simply put, left activists who enter the electoral arena need to promote their initiatives as robustly as possible. Organizing never succeeds in silence. But communicating effectively can get difficult and exhausting. Not all left lawmakers, after all, rate as gifted public speakers or writers. But we all have friends who can help edit our posts and electronic newsletters and polish our presentations at public gatherings. 

Eventually, I started collecting emails at town halls and wherever I spoke, and then, after years of hefty expenditures on a hard-copy newsletter, I moved to publishing a much less expensive email newsletter that could appear more frequently. But I don’t regret any of the dollars I’ve spent on communicating. Keeping your constituents informed between election campaigns ends up keeping the next election campaign less costly. Voters already know you. And the dollars you spend keeping voters informed about what you’re doing also help scare away future potential opponents. 

In sum, communicate! Not using your status as a left lawmaker to educate, agitate, and organize would amount to a gross dereliction of your duties! 

With ever more socialist activists making an impact in the electoral arena, with ever more left activists working in unions, civic life, and issue campaigns to build broad, progressive movements, we’re brewing the political formula for getting this country moving in a way it hasn’t moved since the 1930s. The time has become ripe for real social change. 

Your place in that change may well be an elected office.

Did you enjoy this article?

Becoming a member is the best way to ensure we keep publishing articles that meet the moment. Memberships start at just $5 a month and come along with a variety of other perks; join us today.

Tagged

About the Author